The Responsible Investment Association Australasia (RIAA) welcomes the Government's proposed changes to the annual superannuation performance test. These include a new CPI-plus benchmark for emerging assets not well represented by existing market indices, extending the test to externally directed accumulation products, and allowing the market indices used in the test to be set outside the Regulations.
RIAA says a CPI-plus benchmark for emerging assets is a sensible first step, but more reform is needed to fix the test’s structural problems.
Several elements of the package reflect RIAA's submission, including moving benchmark indices out of the Regulations, periodic reviews of the test every three to five years, separate margins for growth and defensive assets, and applying the new benchmark only to new investments.
“RIAA supports a superannuation performance test that helps safeguard the retirement savings of Australians. The current test has succeeded in removing a number of underperforming funds from the market,” said Estelle Parker, Co-CEO of RIAA.
“But the current design is no longer fit-for-purpose. It leads to benchmark-hugging and discouraging long-term decision-making. This reduces the sector's ability to respond to a changing economy, including the necessary transition to net zero.”
These concerns aren't only about responsible investment. They're also about how the test affects which asset classes funds can invest in, timing, and long-term decision-making outside of climate or sustainability considerations.
“I understand how difficult it is to achieve policy reform, especially in such a sensitive area. So, I congratulate the Treasurer on today's announcement. Given the different perspectives in the industry, it's not been easy. But we need to go further. Even with these changes, the problems of short-termism and constraints on funds' ability to cater to member choice will persist.”
A barrier removed is not capital directed
RIAA cautions against presenting the reforms as a way to direct capital into particular sectors or favour one investment style over another, including estimates that the changes could unlock up to $90 billion of investment.
“Changes to the performance test alone cannot guarantee more capital flowing to particular sectors or Government priorities,” said Ms Parker. “Reform should make sure the test doesn't unduly constrain long-term investing, limit what trustees can invest in, or distort market outcomes. Where trustees are able to take a longer-term or more systemic view, any resulting changes in capital allocation should be understood as the operation of a better-functioning market, not as a policy failure if capital does not move in a particular direction.”
RIAA says performance test reform must be part of a whole-of-government approach. It needs to come with other policies and incentives that encourage investment in targeted asset classes and sectors.
Structural issues remain
RIAA says several features of the test may still operate as a barrier to trustee decision-making:
• Benchmark concentration: RIAA welcomes the move to allow benchmark indices to be set outside the Regulations, which it called for in its submission. However, until new indices are specified, the test will continue to pull the market toward a narrow set of carbon-intensive indices, dampening competition and innovation. RIAA supports extending the test to externally directed products to strengthen member protection, but notes this will bring more products into comparison against a limited number of indices.
• Short-termism: The test encourages funds which exist to make long-term investments to make decisions aimed at passing next year's result. Its lookback period also suits long-horizon assets poorly, such as venture capital, renewables and affordable housing, which often have J-curve returns.
• Consequences of failing the test: If a product fails, the fund must write to members. If it fails twice in a row, it can't take new members. These consequences were designed for default products and weren't reviewed when the test was extended to trustee-directed products. With externally directed products set to face the same consequences from the 2028–29 test, RIAA supports targeted recalibration rather than removing accountability.
• Fees: The test measures performance over many years but captures only a single-year snapshot of administration fees. The proposed changes to the platform fee benchmark do not address this.
“A member of a superannuation fund may deliberately choose a high-growth option with an investment horizon of eight years or longer,” said Ms Parker. “Closing that option to new members after two years of relative underperformance doesn't always fit with member choice. If the consequences of failing are driving the behaviours this reform is trying to fix, benchmark changes alone can only go so far.”
Views on the test differ across the industry, including within RIAA's more than 500 members. RIAA thanks its members for their strong engagement to date. RIAA looks forward to carefully considering the proposal and engaging with its members during the public consultation.
Media enquiries: For further information, please contact Isabella Marotta, Marketing & Communications Coordinator, RIAA, isabella@responsibleinvestment.org.


