Their perspectives highlight a common theme: effective labels must be clear enough for consumers to navigate with confidence, flexible enough to accommodate different investment approaches, and supported by robust evidence that substantiates sustainability claims.
Q1: What is the single biggest lesson from the EU SFDR or UK SDR that Australia should learn from?
Laurin Pfeifer - Regional Lead APAC at Net Purpose: First, define the audience for the labels, the objective of the regime, and mandate measurement of results.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) in the UK set a strong example with the SDR framework designed to speak to consumers, reduce greenwashing risk, enable differentiation between different strategies, and measure real outcomes. The SDR labelling system was easier to understand than SFDR, which was being used as a de facto label regime but neither intended nor suitable for being one.
The European Union responded with SFDR 2.0 to align more closely with the UK. Second, a regime should set incentives for funds to participate while giving consumers what they need: clarity on a labelled fund's objective and the evidence behind it. Here, implementation matters as much as design: adoption of labels will suffer unless there is a clear understanding of how the regime will be applied by the regulator in practice.
Billy Cotter - Head of ESG at Harvest by Dasseti: Proper preparation, and the pragmatism to build a regime that actually works for the full market, not just the largest players.
SFDR was implemented before firms, especially private markets firms, had any real infrastructure to disclose in an auditable way. The result was predictable: funds defaulted to the middle bucket. Article 8 became a catch-all, Article 9 became a restricted club dominated by managers with the budget to sustain the compliance burden, and a lot of genuinely impact-aligned funds were priced out.
SDR took a more pragmatic approach. The labels, Sustainability Focus, Sustainability Improvers, Sustainability Impact, Sustainability Mixed Goals, actually describe what a fund does. Article 6, 8 and 9 do not.
Investors today are prioritising returns and proof of value creation alongside sustainability. Australia should take the mandatory disclosure intent of SFDR and combine it with the label flexibility of SDR. It should also allow for an "impact aligned" category, not just pure impact.
Q2: Are Australian funds currently disclosing enough on how ESG is integrated into their investment process?
Laurin: Measure outcomes. One lesson from SFDR is that implementation can be very challenging if the regulation is over-prescriptive (prescribing which metrics must be used, or which assets are ineligible). Instead, SDR mandates that sustainable objectives must be backed by clear, measurable outcomes, which creates more space for product innovation and puts the onus on the manager to define this. If a fund claims 70% of assets align with its objective, it should show the data behind that number and report against it.
This keeps the regime principles-based and open to new strategies: it regulates the quality of the claim, not the design of the product - of course it’s then paramount for the regulator to uphold that principles-based approach in practice. Greenwashing rarely survives the question “show me the evidence” - so make that question the standard.
Billy: Yes and no. The policies are there: sustainability reports, PRI disclosures, DDQ responses, but it's largely qualitative, and it rarely includes the evidence-based examples investors actually want.
What LPs consistently ask for is outcomes and anecdotes, not process descriptions. The managers that stand out can point to a real example of how an ESG lens changed a decision. We work with a client invested in a company providing sustainable cooking fuels in India. When the war in Iran caused natural gas prices to nearly quadruple, that company's product became cheaper than the alternative — and it's now outperforming its peers. That is ESG integration, and it's a financial argument as much as a sustainability one.
Australia has a mature investment landscape. What's missing is structured guidance on the output, the kind of accountability SFDR introduced, where a significant movement in a key metric required an explanation.
Q3: Consumers don't intuitively understand the difference between "responsible", "sustainable" and "impact". Should labelling try to teach the difference?
Laurin: The dictionary definition of a label is a word or phrase used to describe something. So yes, we do believe labels should help the consumer understand “what’s in the tin”.
However, given the wide variety of sustainable themes, objectives and strategies, labels will need to be broad enough to allow for product innovation, but consistent enough to reflect a fund’s objective. The UK has done a good job here with SDR: they have created broad labels to reflect common strategies (Sustainability Focus, Sustainability Impact, Sustainability Improvers), but asked managers to state objectives and measure outcomes as the test of the fund strategy.
Billy: No, but it should make the difference obvious. Trying to educate consumers through a label is the wrong approach. People don't need a definition of "impact", they need to see what the fund is actually trying to achieve. That is what makes the distinction self-evident. Providing the flexibility to managers so they can tell their own story whilst remaining accountable is the best approach.
The Kilter Rural Murray-Darling Basin Balanced Water Fund is a good example, with a clear stated aim in the fund's title, investors are left in no doubt (nor should they be with the recent performance of this fund). Compare that to a fund labelled "responsible" with no stated outcome. The difference is immediately clear, not because anyone explained it, but because one label has substance and the other doesn't.
The answer to consumer confusion isn't more education. It's better labels, ones that describe a specific strategy and a measurable aim, so the distinction between responsible, sustainable, and impact emerges naturally from what each fund is actually doing.
Q4: What's the most useful minimum standard a labelling regime should set to protect against greenwashing without killing product innovation?
Laurin: Australia has long been a leader in ethical, responsible, and ESG investing and has a number of strategies aimed at achieving financial returns while doing so “ethically”.
It’s worth noting, however, that ESG integration (focused on mitigating financial risk) is not the same as setting sustainable objectives (focused on achieving measurable outcomes), and the latter is the foundation of labelling regimes in the EU and UK. Global markets are becoming more focused on achieving real-world outcomes through sustainable strategies, rather than measuring policies, inputs, or mitigating financial risk. Australia has an opportunity to be a leader in measuring the real-world outcomes of investment portfolios, just like it was in ESG, while not sacrificing on financial return.
Billy: Mandatory disclosure on the low-hanging fruit and make it a carrot, not a stick.
In Australia, the most accessible starting point is financed emissions. Scope 1 and 2 are calculable by almost any company using widely available tools. Carbon disclosure is not the specialist exercise most people assume. You need energy consumption data and a methodology, not an in-house specialist.
Beyond emissions, two additions matter. First, DEI metrics, widely reported and relevant. Second, policy disclosure: whether a firm has an energy management policy, a water management policy, an anonymous reporting line. A simple yes/no binary with a clear definition allows meaningful judgments about trajectory. If a company has an energy management policy, you'd expect emissions to be declining. That context turns a data point into an insight.
Give managers a broad list to choose from, not a fixed mandatory set, preserving flexibility while maintaining accountability.
<hr>
<small> Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the view or position of the Responsible Investment Association Australasia (RIAA).This article is intended as general information and should not be considered investment advice. It is recommended to seek appropriate professional advice before making any investment decisions.
Laurin Pfeifer represents Net Purpose in APAC out of Melbourne. Before that, he spent three years in the UK helping investors integrate Net Purpose’s sustainability data into their workflows, including many managers seeking UK SDR fund labels. His eight years in impact and sustainable investing began at the European Investment Bank and blended-finance impact fund manager Finance in Motion.
Billy leads the Harvest product at Dasseti, a Nasdaq-backed, AI-native ESG and climate reporting solution purpose-built for superannuation funds and asset managers. As a founding team member, Billy has extensive experience developing AI-native solutions to standardise data capture and analysis across the private market lifecycle.
Recently relocated from London to Hong Kong to lead Harvest’s APAC expansion, he brings a global perspective on the intersection of responsible AI, climate regulation, and investor demands for actionable data.
Billy serves as a strategic advisor to Dasseti’s institutional clients, helping them centralise financial and sustainability data to navigate the complexities of opaque, unlisted portfolios. Drawing on deep experience with SFDR and TCFD, he bridges the gap between policy and practice, helping investors move beyond compliance toward meaningful value creation.

.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.png)
.jpg)
